Actually at the ISP I work for we do monitor for botnet activity. It's
really not that hard to notice them either. You really have to not
know anything or just not care to miss the traffic. I've cut off more
then one use because of issues like. After cutting them off I'll give
them a call and tell them why, offer proof, explain the proof (ie make
them type ipconfig /all so they can see their mac address because it
adds validity in their eyes), then I refer them to a computer store we
also own. Generally they are happy that we noticed so they can get
their machines cleaned up.
On 5/17/06, *Gaddis, Jeremy L.* <jeremy@xxxxxxxxxxxx
<mailto:jeremy@xxxxxxxxxxxx>> wrote:
nocfed wrote:
> And if the ISP's could get their act together then most of the
botnets
> would be no more. This _IS_ something that can be controlled, to an
> extent. Many of the network administrators need a course in
> Networking 101 which will greatly assist in tracking down the source
> of attacks. If botnets are required to use their own IP's then how
> hard would it really be to track them down and disable them?
> Disruption of the end users connection and a flag on their account
> should clean them up, although not 100%. So if you want someone to
> blame, blame the ISP, blame the hosting service, and blame the end
> user.
While I agree (mostly), getting the ISPs to do what you suggest will
never happen. If I, Joe Clueless User, have a bot running on my PC
spamming half the world, and my ISP notices this and shuts me off,
what
will I do? Assuming I'm like the majority of users and either a)
don't
know, or b) don't care what they're talking about, I'll cancel my
account and switch to another ISP (that won't shut me off). To do
what
you suggest would be for the greater good of the whole "Internet
community", but would negatively affect $ISP's bottom line. Since we
all know they only care about themselves, well, draw your own
conclusions...
-j
--
Jeremy L. Gaddis
GCWN, MCP, Linux+, Network+
http://www.jeremygaddis.com/
_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/
<http://secunia.com/>
--
-- h0 h0 h0 --
www.nopsled.net <http://www.nopsled.net>
------------------------------------------------------------------------
_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/