Re: [Full-disclosure] Florida Power & Light Company (FPL) Fort Sumner Wind turbine Control SCADA was HACKED

[Jeffrey Walton <noloader@xxxxxxxxx>]

On Sun, Apr 17, 2011 at 10:46 AM,  <Valdis.Kletnieks@xxxxxx> wrote:
> On Sun, 17 Apr 2011 07:39:58 EDT, Jeffrey Walton said:
>
>> To pay devil's advocate here: FPL placed those hosts on a public internet.
>> In addition, FPL also configured the hosts to advertise services. If FPL did
>> not want the services accessed, the company would have removed the hosts
>> from the public internet, shut down the services, or used leased [private]
>> lines. Where's the leap to a criminal offense?
>
> You're welcome to go ahead and break into a house, and use the excuse "but the
> door facing the street was unlocked".  Let is know if the judge is amused.
I was thinking more along the lines of an Office Depot, Sports
Authority, Verizon Wireless, etc - public businesses which
automatically open the sliding glass doors for you. I don't expect
these businesses to claim a 'comparison shopper' was trespassing after
the fact.

> Most of the applicable statutes are worded in such a way that the "but it was
> wide open and unsecured" claim won't do any good, as they are phrased in terms
> of "exceeding authorized access".
One cannot know these things for all public IP addresses 'a priori'.
If the network is not meant to be accessed, it should not be
advertising services, or it should be on a leased line.

> You go in knowing you don't have an
> authorized access code, you're screwed.
Anonymous logins are available for many services - for example, FTP
and WWW. Its a mainstay of the internet, and has been so for many
years.

> Oh, and many of the statutes *do not*
> include "intent" in them.  So whether you're a black hat doing something evil,
> or a white hat investigating so you can tell them they have a problem, you're
> still in trouble.
Intent has nothing to do with using public services (I'm not sure how
to articulate it as a legal argument - sorry). If they are available
and used, don't complain after the fact. If a company does not want
them used, they should not advertise the service, or they should
purchase a leased line.

Jeff

_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/