Re: [Full-disclosure] full disclosure is an intelligence blackhole

["McGhee, Eddie" <Eddie.McGhee@xxxxxxx>]

Come on mate seriously its getting boring, if any serious security threats are 
out there then drop the info and man up, stop with the bullshit of making 
netdev a poor internet meme, because that's all it is.. 

-----Original Message-----
From: full-disclosure-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx 
[mailto:full-disclosure-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of intel unit
Sent: 01 March 2010 08:06
To: full-disclosure@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: [Full-disclosure] full disclosure is an intelligence blackhole

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

John Cartwright is perpetrating global conflict by censoring n3td3v's 0days and 
commenting.
Opinion by Andrew Wallace. Published by a believer in free speech who knows 
Andrew Wallace is an super spy expert. Luyk a jelly samwich amirite?


Is banning people from a mailing list a national security risk?

We haven't been on the mailing list since January 2009, although there have 
been plenty of hackers trying to impersonate us.

For sure the impersonations are misleading, and we would like to ask, is 
banning people from a mailing list a vulnerability?

Let's just say we haven't been able to release any information to the public 
for over a year now.

We don't have anywhere we can post information.

Isn't it a security risk to ban one the biggest security & intelligence groups 
in the UK from posting?

We think so, and why would you want to create a climate where there are plenty 
n3td3v wanna be's posting to the mailing list, but no actual intelligence on 
what we're upto, what we've been researching or anything like that.

A security & intelligence group with over 6000 security professionals in jobs 
around the world who make up the n3td3v group, banned from making announcements 
relating to national security matters.

A whole year of no information getting out to the security industry about the 
vulnerabilities in national security and other research that we've been getting 
upto.

None of that has been post, its all been supressed.

By who? One man decided to risk security by banning one of the largest security 
groups in the United Kingdom.

We were treated badly on the mailing list, it wasn't us in the wrong, we only 
defended ourselves and the integrity of our group from people who were 
obviously wanting an argument.

We aren't playing around, we are grown adults who are serious about security & 
intelligence.

We were made out to be something that we weren't, its not nice to be treated 
like that.

It's why the mailing list can't be taken seriously and poses a risk to national 
security.

Because the people who do research security aren't able to post on the mailing 
list.

And I don't know why more people haven't spoken out about an organisation as 
big as n3td3v being banned from the mailing list, its a risk to national 
security.

We don't post our intelligence anywhere else apart from the mailing list we've 
been banned from, and we don't give out any signals intelligence about what we 
are getting upto, we're very careful about that.

The only opportunity to find out what the n3td3v security and intelligence 
group were upto was being subscribed to the mailing list and reading our emails.

Andrew is banned, and banned with that are the voices of over 6000 and more 
researchers, security consultants and many others.

Is banning n3td3v from Full-disclosure mailing list a national security issue? 
Of course it is.

National security has been at risk for over a year and will remain at risk... 
because the information flow has been cut off.

Who will be to blame? One man who runs the mailing list, one man will need to 
live with himself, his name is John Cartwright.

He has cut off a major security research and intelligence group on purpose, I 
don't think he cares about national security.

Can he live with himself?

We've been sitting in our offices wondering this for over a year, we've held 
security conferences with our members and other stuff and remain frustrated 
that we've been cut off from communicating with the security industry.

Yours faithfully,

n3td3v security
& intelligence group
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Charset: UTF8
Note: This signature can be verified at https://www.hushtools.com/verify
Version: Hush 3.0

wpwEAQMCAAYFAkuLdX8ACgkQwGoky+I7EouDgAP5AUjZ2+mKCx4dduWJlNWgAN8IwnkL
PqokbvRhGDeHoWCBWeTjqoYxh49Z2fzA4EIcrtmL7miGfXicLHWJyBoSriMUFL97IYe3
hAziWzbIanVTbqftrz1ayRVx0k3vdu/5Hwocda6lCmgivdLjWhrL0UaKby3LQbc1nBqB
mCK69YQ=
=xM2C
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/

_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://secunia.com/